จริยธรรมการพิมพ์
Publication Ethics and Handling of Misconduct
The journal is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, and reliability of the scholarly record. This policy is based on the ethical principles and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), together with relevant research and publication standards. Editors, reviewers, and authors are required to observe the following duties and responsibilities.
- Ethics and Responsibilities of Editors
1.1 Editorial Decisions: Editors are responsible for deciding whether to accept, request revision of, or reject manuscripts based on their alignment with the journal’s aim and scope, academic accuracy and quality, originality, significance of the findings, and ethical considerations. Decisions must be made without discrimination based on race, nationality, sex, gender identity, age, religion, belief, institutional affiliation, or any other status unrelated to the quality of the work.
1.2 Fairness and Independence: Editors must conduct the editorial process fairly, transparently, and free from commercial, political, institutional, or personal influence. A communicated decision may be reconsidered when a reasoned appeal is submitted, a significant procedural error is identified, or new ethical information emerges that may affect the decision.
1.3 Confidentiality: Editors must keep manuscripts, author information, reviewer reports, and all other information related to the editorial process confidential. Data or findings contained in unpublished manuscripts must not be used for personal benefit.
1.4 Conflicts of Interest: When an editor has a relationship or interest that may affect, or reasonably be perceived to affect, impartiality, the editor must disclose the conflict and withdraw from handling the manuscript. Responsibility must be assigned to another editor who has no conflict of interest.
1.5 Handling Complaints and Allegations: When a complaint is received or suspected misconduct is identified, editors must act fairly, confidentially, and in proportion to the available evidence. Relevant parties must be given an opportunity to respond, and the journal may contact the authors’ institutions, regulatory bodies, funders, other journals, or other relevant organizations when necessary.
1.6 Research Ethics and Personal Data: Editors must verify that research involving humans or animals has received approval, or a formal exemption, from a competent ethics committee as required by applicable law and disciplinary standards. Publication of data, images, or details that may identify an individual requires appropriate consent or an exemption approved by an ethics committee in accordance with applicable law.
1.7 Maintaining the Accuracy of the Scholarly Record: When an error or concern affecting the reliability of an article is identified, editors must take appropriate action, such as publishing a correction, issuing an expression of concern, or retracting the article. Such notices must be accessible, linked to the original article, and clearly state the reasons for the action.
Details concerning peer review, appeals, and the use of artificial intelligence are governed by the journal’s Peer Review Policy and Artificial Intelligence Use Policy.
- Ethics and Responsibilities of Reviewers
2.1 Contribution to Editorial Decisions: Reviewers are responsible for evaluating the quality, accuracy, methodological rigor, significance of the findings, and alignment of the manuscript with the journal’s scope. Reviews must provide clear, well-reasoned, and constructive comments.
2.2 Suitability and Timeliness: Reviewers who lack sufficient expertise or are unable to complete a review within the specified timeframe must promptly inform the Editor and decline the invitation.
2.3 Confidentiality: Manuscripts or related information must not be entered into external artificial intelligence systems that have not been approved by the journal or that cannot provide adequate assurances of confidentiality and data protection. Any use of artificial intelligence during peer review must comply with the journal’s Artificial Intelligence Use Policy.
2.4 Objectivity: Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts on the basis of their content and scholarly evidence and must avoid disparaging language, personal attacks, and bias unrelated to the quality of the work. Suspected plagiarism, fabrication, falsification or distortion of data, image manipulation, inappropriate citation, or other misconduct must be reported to the Editor. Reviewers must not independently investigate the authors.
2.5 Conflicts of Interest: Reviewers must disclose any academic, professional, financial, personal, or competitive relationships that may affect, or reasonably be perceived to affect, their impartiality. They must withdraw from the review when they cannot provide an independent and fair assessment.
- Ethics and Responsibilities of Authors
3.1 Originality and Citation: Authors must submit their own original work and accurately cite text, ideas, data, images, tables, instruments, or other work produced by others. Plagiarism, undisclosed reuse of an author’s own previously published work, or citation of nonexistent sources constitutes academic misconduct.
3.2 Duplicate Submission and Publication: Authors must not submit the same manuscript, or a manuscript with substantially overlapping content, to more than one journal at the same time. Authors must disclose related previous work and, when requested by the journal, explain how the submitted manuscript differs from it.
3.3 Authorship and Contributions: All listed authors must meet all authorship criteria, including making a substantial contribution to the conception or design of the study, or to the collection, analysis, or interpretation of data; participating in drafting the manuscript or revising it for important academic content; approving the final manuscript; and accepting responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the work. Contributors who do not meet all authorship criteria should be acknowledged as appropriate. The corresponding author must ensure that the author list and order have been approved by all authors. Any addition, removal, or change in author order after submission must be justified and supported by the written consent of all authors.
3.4 Accuracy of Data and Reporting: Authors must report their methods and findings accurately, completely, and transparently. Fabrication, falsification, distortion, selective reporting, or manipulation of data or images in a manner that may mislead readers is prohibited. Authors should follow reporting guidelines appropriate to the study design.
3.5 Research Ethics: Research involving humans or animals must receive approval, or a formal exemption, from a competent ethics committee before the study is conducted. The manuscript must identify the committee, approval or exemption number, and relevant consent information, as appropriate. Research must respect the dignity, rights, safety, privacy, and confidentiality of participants and comply with applicable laws and field-specific standards.
3.6 Funding and Conflicts of Interest: Authors must disclose all sources of funding, the role of the funders, and any financial or non-financial relationships that may influence the design, conduct, interpretation, or reporting of the study. The absence of conflicts of interest must also be stated explicitly.
3.7 Data and Supporting Evidence: Authors must retain the data and supporting evidence underlying their findings for an appropriate period and provide them to the Editor when necessary for verification. This must be done with due regard for participant consent, confidentiality, research ethics, data rights, and applicable personal data protection laws.
Authors should include a Data Availability Statement in the article indicating whether the data are publicly available in a repository, available from the authors under appropriate conditions, or unavailable because of ethical, privacy, legal, or contractual restrictions.
3.8 Use of Artificial Intelligence: Artificial intelligence cannot be listed as an author. Any use of artificial intelligence must be disclosed and must comply with the journal’s Artificial Intelligence Use Policy.
3.9 Post-Publication Corrections: If authors identify a significant error or concern regarding the reliability of a published article, they must promptly inform the Editor and cooperate with any investigation, correction, expression of concern, or retraction, as appropriate.
- Handling of Misconduct
Misconduct includes fabrication, falsification, or distortion of data; plagiarism; duplicate publication; inappropriate division of a single body of research into multiple articles (salami slicing); improper manipulation of authorship; breaches of research ethics; undisclosed conflicts of interest; interference with or manipulation of the review process; breaches of confidentiality; the systematic production, purchase, sale, or procurement of manuscripts through fraudulent processes, including paper mills; and inappropriate use of artificial intelligence.
When an allegation is supported by sufficient information or evidence, the journal will respond impartially, confidentially, and fairly to all parties. The accused party will be given an opportunity to respond and provide evidence. The journal may seek expert advice, suspend the editorial process, or contact the authors’ institutions, regulatory bodies, funders, other journals, or other relevant organizations when concerns are credible and serious, when the matter falls outside the journal’s investigative authority, or when the parties involved fail to respond or provide a reasonable explanation.
The journal’s actions may include dismissing the allegation, requesting corrections, rejecting the manuscript, publishing a Correction, issuing an Expression of Concern, or retracting the article, depending on the facts, severity of the matter, impact on the reliability of the scholarly record, and applicable COPE guidance. Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly record, not to punish the authors.